Eventually, Harvey decides to spend more quality time with his girlfriend.Their relationship hits a breaking point when Sabrina promises to help her manager Josh study on the night of Harvey's big football game.They both survive and Sabrina suspected that they would forget the situation as usual, however, she discovers that Harvey has reached his spell quota and memory spells will no longer work on him.Harvey then rushes into Sabrina's home, asking if they can talk about the fact that she's a witch.Sabrina tells Dreama to page her when and if Harvey ever gets in the game (since he is always on the bench) but Dreama keeps beeping her with false alarms, eventually causing Sabrina to turn the beeper off.Unfortunately, she does so when Harvey finally gets to play, scoring a touchdown for Westbridge.Harvey then gets into a relationship with Colette, but after he and Sabrina talk it out, he ends it with her and he and Sabrina get back together.Near the end of the year, Sabrina casts a spell to choose between Harvey and Josh which forces them to undergo a battle to death.
After Harvey and Dashiell find out about each other, they tell Sabrina to choose one or the other.
Sabrina's aunts agree and they go on a temporary break.
He also makes a close friendship with Valerie, a new girl with whom Sabrina is also close friends.
In Seasons 1-3, they always hang out at their favourite pizza parlor "The Slicery." He is too shy to ask Sabrina out, though still dances with her during the school dance.
He eventually finds the courage to ask her out and from then, they become boyfriend and girlfriend.